The Fishes

User rating 

StarStarStarNo StarNo Star

 4 reviews

Venue Image
North Hinksey Village,
OXFORD,
OX2 0NA

(01865) 249 796

Add a User Review for

The Fishes
Add user review button
Add your own review of this restaurant
Sort By:
User icon
StarStarStarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer maproom
18/01/2012
A gastropub, in a good setting on (a branch of) the Thames, with plenty of outside seating, and a play area for children. The beer is ok - Greene King IPA, plus, usually, a guest beer, always well kept. The food can be excellent, the devilled kidneys offered last autumn were outstanding. Unfortunately it can also be dismal - as experienced on two of my last three visits. One was a rare steak, served at room temperature; the other was a "dish of the day" pork steak, served rare, with blood running out of it. I have learned not to complain, you are too likely to get a snooty young man who claims "it is meant to be like that". And while the food is very variable, the prices are consistently on the high side.
Incidentally, the kitchens now close at 21:00, fair enough in itself, but there is no mention of this in their publicity material.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarNo Star
03/02/2010
Visited The Fishes for the first time on the weekend and were pleasantly suprised; busy, congenial atmosphere; the food was way above standard pub fare and the service [a charming young Australian name of Jac] was great. Think we'll visit again, especially when the weather warms up - the outside eating area and the grounds are lovely [good for us dog people]
Reply to this review
User icon
StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer Spin69
13/04/2009
From the moment we walked into the empty restaurant at 12.15pm on Easter Monday to be told that we couldn't sit down then as we had booked at 1.00pm this didn't bode well.

Finally after arguing with the waiter who trotted out various conflicting reasons: the tables were all booked, the kitchen couldn't cope we were seated.

We ordered the lemon sole (ok) and then the roast lamb which you share. This arrived on a wooden platter looking lovely, several minutes later the plates arrived - irritating but not the end of the world.

We had been informed by the waiter (of the above) that the lamb was served pink. This hadn't seen pink for quite a while and the yorkshire puddings were cold.

The lamb was duly sent back to the kitchen to be replaced with pink, but stringy meat and warmer veg.

Overall the experience was not a pleasant one and certainly one of the worst meals I have experienced in my ten years of Oxford.

It's not just that the food was so bad, the greeting staff were so incredibly rude. No customer in today's credit crunch environment should be told when they can sit down to eat.

Owners of The Fishes sort out your front of house staff, the setting is beautiful and you could be onto a real winner. However with the current situation I doubt it
Reply to this review
User icon
07/08/2009
Thanks for this feedback which I have just spotted I am really sorry you didn't have a great experience.

I know we really tried on the day to get it right for you and your party, and still we didn't succeed in meeting your expectations.

In a busy place like the Fishes on a bank holiday, I would strongly advise anyone to book for the time they want.

As you can well imagine, in order to satisfy all our guests with freshly cooked dishes (no microwaves here!) we have to stick with the times booked.

Otherwise those who did book for the 12.15-12.45 slots will get disappointed by how fast we can cook for them.

Sorry again. We always try to get it right. If you want to try us again, I'd love to make it possible.

Pop an email and we'll make it happen.
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
16/01/2009
The Fishes has a fantastic atmosphere, big conservatory dining room with a deck for civilised otudoor dining. The massive garden is perfect on a summers day. Limited food in the garden, a selection of picnics and occasional BBQ's, however the food is all top quality and while portions can look small the taste is great and you actually don't need more than they serve.
I can't recommend it more highly
Reply to this review
The views contained in these user reviews are not endorsed by ViewOxford in any way and are provided by users who wish to publish their independent views of the respective establishment.
Nearest

What's near The Fishes?

Below are the nearest 5 venues within 500 metres of The Fishes.
Restaurants near The Fishes (0)
Pubs & Bars near The Fishes (0)
Clubs near The Fishes (0)
Cinemas near The Fishes (0)
Hotels near The Fishes (0)

Most Read Today

image
01 O2 Academy Oxford

There are 62 events listed for this venue

image
02 New Theatre Oxford

There are 30 events listed for this venue

image
03 The Mill Arts Centre

There are 17 events listed for this venue

image
04 Oxford Playhouse

There are 17 events listed for this venue

image
05 Purple Turtle

There are 10 events listed for this venue

Content updated: 25/05/2012 13:24

Latest Restaurants User Reviews

  • Dewani Shah
    Best curry around by far. Definitely recommend the madras
    StarStarStarStarStar
    Clumsyland on 07/05/2012 @ 18:18
  • The Merry Miller
    I went there a few weeks ago with a walking group for an after-wa...
    StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
    hamandegg on 05/05/2012 @ 20:17
  • The Merry Miller
    I went there a few weeks ago with a walking group for an after-wa...
    StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
    hamandegg on 05/05/2012 @ 19:58
  • Sojo Restaurant
    why don't you just stay at home and eat, and be the the sad basta...
    StarStarStarStarStar
    hago on 19/04/2012 @ 00:35
  • Windmill Carvery
    An evening spoilt by confusion and rude service. Chef was very fr...
    StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
    DrBB on 14/04/2012 @ 21:25